The Flawless Spot Problem
Earlier, every Tancho spot generated as a near-perfect circle centred between the eyes. Because the spot could not fail, only general body shape and skin lost points.
Nearly 19% of our Tancho reached Champion grade. A koi judge noted that in reality, flawless Tancho become scarcer with every size class. Spots sit off-centre, stretch into ovals, or stay undersized. Now our generation allows the spot to fail in the exact ways a judge looks for.
Top: four Tancho with uniform circular spots. Bottom: spots shifting, stretching into ovals, and shrinking.
Three Spot Genes
We added three genes to Tancho generation, rolled after earlier seed values to keep existing varieties intact:
spotShift: Offsets the spot up to 13% of body width to either side.
spotOval: Distorts the circle into an oval up to 35% longer or wider while preserving surface area.
spotShrink: Reduces overall diameter by up to 40%.
Scoring the Head
Our evaluation pass, JudgeTanchoSpot, measures the spot in true head space:
balance: Evaluates central alignment and roundness. Lateral drift under 7% of radius is forgiven; greater drift scales the score down to zero.
coverage: Compares surface area against the full standard. Up to 20% undersize is accepted without penalty.
head: Confirms the red leaves clean white margins around both eyes.
clear: Confirms a white nose and zero red pigment behind the head.
White skin evenness now uses the raw gene value and counts for 15% of the total score, up from 5%. Regardless of skin quality, a Tancho cannot grade as Champion unless balance, coverage, and head each score 0.7 or higher.
The Results
Across a test run of 2,351 Tancho (seeds 0 to 59,999):
Pond: 10% → 17%
Fine: 26% → 40%
Show: 46% → 38%
Champion: 19% → 4.5%
Tancho Champions now match Kohaku and Ogon rates at roughly 4.5%.

